Indiana and Missouri permit a judge to determine the sentence if jurors cannot reach a unanimous sentencing verdict. All Filters. Join to connect PR. Mr. DuBoise was arrested in connection with Ms. Gramss killing when he was 18. Robert Joseph Dubois, 69, passed away on Saturday, April 16, 2022. Prosecutors in Hillsborough County, Fla., said Robert DuBoise, 55, had been wrongfully convicted. The Innocence Project of Florida provides all legal representation for free. A review by the unit and the Innocence Project found that the injury on Ms. Gramss cheek was not a bite mark and that the jailhouse informant who testified against Mr. DuBoise was not credible, prosecutors said. Robert DuBoise hugging his mother Myra DuBoise following his release from prison after 37 years on Thursday, Aug. 27, 2020 in Bowling Green, Florida. Based on a comparison of the impression and mold, Dr. Souviron determined DuBoise was a match to the mark left on the body and he was arrested immediately. DuBoise will be the 171st documented death-row exoneration in the U.S. since 1973. The lawsuit, first reported by theTampa Bay Times, seeks unspecified damages. Join our mailing list to receive the latest news and updates from the Innocence Project: The CRU announced their collaboration with the Innocence Project to audit prior cases involving bite mark evidence. A free man for the first time since he was a teenager, Mr. DuBoise must now put his life back together after almost 40 years in prison, the lawsuit says. Judge Nash reduced that sentence to time served and set a September 14 hearing date for the presentation of evidence to overturn his conviction. These people do not work for the Innocence Project of Florida. The discovery of a rape kit for victim Barbara Grams, which had been presumed destroyed decades earlier, provided conclusive evidence that Robert DuBoise wasn't guilty of the 19-year-old's 1983 rape and murder. (Page 4) Im just very grateful to all of you.. Robert DuBoise, 56, was freed in August last year after long-shelved untested DNA evidence from a rape kit proved he was innocent of the rape and murder of 19-year-old Barbara Grams in Tampa . 6 Wrongful Convictions That Were Overturned. Create your free profile and get access to exclusive content. If you believe you have been contacted by such a person, pleasecontact us. A man in Florida who was exonerated after spending 37 years in prison for a 1983 rape and murder filed a lawsuit against police officials and the forensic dentist who testified against him, claiming they knowingly fabricated evidence used to convict him. The Innocence Project is affiliated with Benjamin N. Cardozo School of Law, Yeshiva University. Robert DuBoise, exonerated of 1983 murder, sues Tampa over imprisonment, Raymond Odierno, Army general who commanded in Iraq, dies of cancer at age 67, Justin McNeil appointed as new Jefferson County Supervisor of Elections, Antisemitic message distributor faces consequences in Palm Beach County court, Rick Scott says Democrats should be worried if Joe Biden is 2024 nominee, Last Call for 3.1.23 A prime-time read of whats going down in Florida politics, Jason Brodeur wants pay-to-play blog posts about elected officials reported with the state, Kamala Harris to speak at Miami Beach climate innovation summit. DuBoise was found guilty and initially sentenced to death, according to the documents. A Florida man who was wrongfully convicted of raping and murdering a woman walked free Thursday after 37 years behind bars. He served three years on death row before the Florida Supreme Court vacated his death sentence. DuBoise was re-sentenced to life for the murder and 15 years for the attempted sexual battery to run consecutively. A Florida man exonerated of a 1983 rape and murder after serving 37 years in prison is suing over his wrongful conviction in which a disproven bite mark was crucial evidence. trial court has freed a former death-row prisoner after local prosecutors said new DNA evidence had proven his innocence of the rape and murder for which he was wrongfully convicted and sentenced to death 37 years ago. The DNA profile was entered into CODIS and matched to an individual who had no connection to DuBoise. The Conviction Review Unit (CRU) at the Office of the State Attorney for the 13th Judicial Circuit has announced that in light of the clear injustice that occurred in this case and the discreditation of bite mark analysis as a reliable scientific technique, they will collaborate with the Innocence Project to review Hillsborough County cases that utilized bite mark evidence to secure a conviction. He was released from prison last month. Weve had an innocent man locked up for a crime that he did not commit, while the real perpetrator was never held accountable for this horrific murder, Andrew H. Warren, the Hillsborough County state attorney, said at a news conference on Wednesday. The complaint, filed in the U.S. District Court for the Middle District of Florida, against former Tampa police Detectives Phillip Saladino and K.E. Pennsylvania man who wrongly spent 23 years on death row is freed, Original reporting and incisive analysis, direct from the Guardian every morning. Unlike other areas of forensic analysis, bite mark analysis lacks validated rules, regulations or processes for accreditation that would establish standards for the expert testimony. I praise them for all they did. All Rights Reserved. Photo of Robert DuBois hugging his mother by Martha Asencio-Rhine, Tampa BayTimes. In 2019, the Innocence Project reached out to the Conviction Review Unit (CRU) at the Office of the State Attorney for the 13th Judicial Circuit in Tampa to begin a joint re-investigation based on new evidence on the jailhouse informant and concerns about the discredited bite mark evidence. Report this profile . In fact, the victims injury was not a human bitemark at all, Daniel Marshall, an attorney for the Human Rights Defense Center, wrote in the lawsuit. In fact, the original prosecutions case rested rested primarily on two pieces of evidence:the testimony of a fellow inmate, and a woundon the woman's cheek that a dental expert identified as a bite mark from DuBoise's teeth, according to. View FREE Public Profile & Reputation for Robert Dubois in Titusville, FL - See Court Records | Photos | Address, Emails & Phone Number | Personal Review | $70 - $79,999 Income & Net Worth [emailprotected]. Robert DuBoise, 56, wasfreed from prison in August 2020 after long-shelved, untested DNA evidence from a rape kit proved he was innocent of the slaying of 19-year-old Barbara Grams in Tampa. Good Luck Mr. DuBoise have a blessed life and enjoy every moment to the fullest. was wrongfully convicted of raping and murdering a woman walked free Thursday after 37 years behind bars. Resides in Fort Lauderdale, FL. Have a tip or story idea? The brother and friend were never charged because there was no other evidence against them, prosecutors said. Robert is related to Robert Eric Dubois and Mary Frances Dubois as well as 3 additional people. His sentence was reduced in 1988 to life in prison until his exoneration and release last year. After a 2008 hearing, a judge concluded that even if the evidence was suitable for testing, it would not exonerate DuBoise because the states theory was that two other individuals participated in the crime. No other physical evidence linked DuBoise to the crime. When investigators began to identify suspects, they also came across a local resident who referred to Robert DuBoise as someone who caused problems at a hangout place in the area. Link your TV provider to stream full episodes and live TV. Chris Bumbaca. I never lost faith that today would come. All original evidence was thought to have been destroyed, as was noted by the court at an earlier time Soon after this discovery, DNA testing on the remaining evidence revealed positive identification of male DNA from the perpetrator and excluded Robert DuBoise as a contributor. DuBoise was released from the Hardee Correctional Institution in Bowling Green, Florida, August 27, 2020, one day after Hillsborough prosecutors and lawyers from the national Innocence Project and the Innocence Project of Florida presented Circuit Judge Christopher Nash with evidence of his innocence. ROBERT DUBOIS SALES at PR Winter Park, Florida, United States. He has been living in a Tampa center for people wrongfully imprisoned and has said he must learn the ways of modern life, from shopping at Walmart to using an iPhone. His innocence was proven after a review of the case by the Hillsborough county state attorneys office and the Innocence Project, which works nationwide. Robert A. Dubois Obituary. Robert DuBoise, 56, was freed in August last year after long-shelved untested DNA evidence from a rape kit proved he was innocent of the rape and murder of 19-year-old Barbara Grams in Tampa. The Conviction Review Unit will continue to work with the court to finish exonerating DuBoise,Hall said in a phone interview with Oxygen.com. and indictments stem from bite mark evidence, and the misapplication of forensic science was involved in 45 percent of DNA exoneration cases. 14 connections. Dr. Richard Souviron, a forensic odontologist, advised detectives to obtain bite mark impressions from potential suspects. In 2006, DuBoise sought post-conviction DNA testing, but an evidence search at the time revealed that all evidence admitted at trial, which included evidence collected as part of the rape kit, was destroyed in 1990. Finally, the Conviction Review Unit discoveredthat Gramsrape kit hadnt been destroyed after all. A free man for the first time since he was a teenager, Mr DuBoise must now put his life back together after almost 40 years in prison, the lawsuit says. Florida State Attorney's Office, Floridas newly established Conviction Review Unit agreed to review DuBoises case in September 2019, according to a, For one thing,the injury on Gramscheek likely wasnt a bite mark at all and even if it was, bite marks are no longer considered reliable evidence in identifying suspects, according to new expert testimony referenced in. Website by MADEO. The state took 37 years away from Robert, Friedman said. If you believe you have been contacted by such a person, please. The jailhouse informants testimony has also been discredited. Reserved. The murder will return to the unsolved file. Robert DuBoise was convicted at a trial that relied on a testimony from an unreliable jailhouse informant and faulty bite-mark analysis. Through observation and autopsy, authorities concluded the woman was raped and beaten to death. Help us advocate for the innocent by sharing the latest news from the Innocence Project. Please avoid sharing any personal information in the comments below and join us in making this a hate-speech free and safe space for everyone. A jury convicted Mr. DuBoise of first-degree murder and attempted sexual battery in 1985, and a judge sentenced him to death. In many wrongful convictions, such as DuBoises, these benefits provided in exchange for their testimony are never disclosed. Although DuBoise was the charged perpetrator, there was no other physical or circumstantial evidence connecting him to the attack. DuBoise has not yet been officially exonerated. No state any longer permits a judge to override a jurys recommendation for life. They deserve the truth, not false closure based on a false story. Robert N Dubois Address: 3600 Oak Tree Ln Titusville, FL 32780 Name: Robert N Dubois Address: 3600 Oak Tree Ln Titusville, FL 32780 Phone: (321) 544-5346 Dwelling Type: Single Family Dwelling Unit Length of Residence: Under one year Median Home Value: $975,000 Median Household Income: $578,000 Vehicle: 2003 NISSAN FRONTIER Report ID: 42214660 For 37 years, weve had an innocent man locked up in prisonwhile the real perpetrator was never held accountable for this heinous crime. He was released on . He has always maintained his innocence, but any hope of reversing his. The testimony of DuBoises fellow inmate was also called into doubt. The Medical Examiner also identified what was thought to be a human bite-mark on the victims cheek. After 37 years behind bars, a Florida man was formally cleared on Monday of a 1983 rape and murder which DNA evidence proved he did not commit. On Wednesday, prosecutors said they had moved to free Mr. DuBoise by filing a joint motion with his lawyer to reduce his life sentence to time served. On September 14, 2020, Robert DuBoise became the 30th person exonerated from Florida's death row. After 37 years of being incarcerated for a crime he did not commit, Robert DuBoise was expected to be released from prison on Thursday, according to a press release from Hillsborough State. Thank you for visiting us. On Monday, a hearing before Hillsborough county judge Christopher Nash resulted in an order wiping away the convictions and life sentence, and removing DuBoise from the state sex offender registry. In March 1985, a jury convicted DuBoise of capital murder and attempted sexual battery. DuBoise was resentenced to life for the murder and 15 years for the attempted sexual battery to run consecutively. In 2014, the Florida Supreme Court adopted a rule of criminal procedure requiring the prosecution to disclose impeachment evidence on jailhouse informants within 15 days of the defense requesting discovery materials. DuBoise never confessed and maintained his innocence throughout, his lawyers said. At the time, the inmate, who was facing a life sentence, claimed hed received no promises in exchange for testimony. During the medical examiners autopsy, he found a pattern injury on the victims face that was determined to be a human bite mark inflicted around the time of her death. The Innocence Project began investigating DuBoises case in 2018 due to both the unreliable informant testimony and flawed bite mark analysis on which the case rested. Judge Christopher. This bitemark evidence was knowingly fabricated by Defendant Souviron, a forensic odontologist, in conspiracy with Detectives K.E. The American Board of Forensic Odontology (ABFO) has revised its standards and guidelines, and now explicitly states that an ABFO Diplomate shall not express conclusions unconditionally linking a bite mark to a dentition.. Robert DuBoise, 56, was freed from prison in August 2020 after long-shelved, untested DNA evidence from a rape kit proved he was innocent of the slaying of 19-year-old Barbara Grams in Tampa.. Todays exoneration finally removes the shackles from Robert DuBoise. Mr. DuBoises father died while he was incarcerated, she said. So when he heard the news he was thrilled, but his reaction was, Its like waking up from a nightmare., Ms. Gramss family could not immediately be reached for comment on Wednesday. A Florida man who was wrongfully convicted of raping and murdering a woman walked free Thursday after 37 years behind bars. Jerry Lambe is a journalist at Law&Crime. The lawsuit claims beeswax was not an accepted method of identifying teeth marks in murder cases and was used only because another officer in the Tampa police department operated a honey business on the side. Knowing that such an egregious mistake could happen here is gut-wrenching.. One of them who was a major contributor of DNA on the samples meaning more of his genetic material was present is now considered a person of interest in the killing of Ms. Grams, who was found raped and beaten to death behind a Tampa dental office in 1983. Far right Republicans wanted him executed years ago. In the federal lawsuit filed this week, DuBoises attorneys name as defendants the city of Tampa, four police investigators and a forensic dentist who testified a bite mark on Grams cheek was from DuBoise based on a faulty beeswax mold made of his teeth. He always believed that the truth would come to light., DNA Evidence Exonerates Man in 1983 Rape and Killing, Prosecutors Say, https://www.nytimes.com/2020/08/26/us/robert-duboise-wrongful-conviction.html. Souviron famously helped authorities convict Ted Bundy for the 1979 murder of Lisa Levy based on the bite mark the notorious serial killer left on the victims buttocks. The lawsuit, first reported by the Tampa Bay Times, seeks unspecified damages. Anyone can read what you share. Or to keep it anonymous, click here. Jailhouse informant testimony plays a leading role in 17% of the 375 DNA-based exoneration cases. Right; Robert outside his home in Tampa, Florida, in October 2020. DuBoise has been deprived of all the basic pleasures of human experience, which all free people enjoy as a matter of right., Have a tip we should know? The only physical evidence implicating Mr. DuBoise was fabricated bitemark evidence that supposedly matched Mr. DuBoise to an injury on the victims body. Fraud Alert:We have heard that there are people who fraudulently represent themselves as working for the Innocence Project of Florida, promising legal representation in exchange for money. Case Summary. In fact, the victims injury was not a human bite mark at all, wroteDaniel Marshall, an attorney for the Human Rights Defense Center representing DuBoise. DNA testing of the samples confirmed what Mr. DuBoise had long said: that he was not responsible for the rape and murder of the woman, Barbara Grams, 19, prosecutors said. The jury recommended a life sentence, but the judge overrode the recommendation and sentenced DuBoise to death. That process has since been abolished, Kamm said. (August 27, 2020 Tampa, Florida) Today, Robert DuBoise walked free after spending almost 37 years in prison for a 1983 rape and murder in Tampa, Florida, he did not commit. This is the first type of audit to be done by a CRU. Robert Dubois in Miami, FL 12 results - Robert Dubois may also have lived outside of Miami, such as Saint Petersburg, Fort Lauderdale and 2 other cities in Florida. Robert has spent over 36 years in prison because of discredited bite mark evidence and the testimony of an unreliable jailhouse informant who we now know received benefits in exchange for that testimony. Wrongful convictions deprive victims and their families of justice; they deserve the truthnot false closure based on a false story. Photo: As the case headed for trial, the State used a jailhouse informant to help build its case. The Innocence Project began investigating DuBoises case in 2018 and in 2019 and requested that the CRU reopen the case based on new evidence about the jailhouse informant and concerns about the discredited bite mark evidence. By 2018, it was well known that bite mark evidence had led to wrongful convictions. His innocence was proven after a review of the case by the Hillsborough County state attorneys office and the Innocence Project, which works nationwide to free prisoners who are wrongly convicted. In 2007, pursuant to a court order the state responded that in 1990 the Hillsborough County Clerks Office disposed of the evidence in the regular course of business. Defense counsel met with a Tampa Police Department detective to determine whether any items not admitted at trial were in the police departments custody, at which time approximately ten boxes of evidence were foundmostly trace evidence. On August 19, 1983, a young womans body was found behind a dental office in Tampa, Florida. Finally, the state took 37 years behind bars reported by the Bay! Had led to wrongful convictions deprive victims and their families of justice robert dubois florida deserve. Link your TV provider to stream full episodes and live TV judge sentenced to... Their families of justice ; they deserve the truthnot false closure based on false... In Hillsborough County, Fla., said Robert DuBoise became the 30th person exonerated Florida! Evidence against them, prosecutors said DuBoise have a blessed life and enjoy every moment the! Evidence that supposedly matched Mr. DuBoise have a blessed life and enjoy every moment to the documents death... To stream full episodes and live TV womans body was found behind a dental office in Tampa Florida! Home in Tampa robert dubois florida Florida, in conspiracy with detectives K.E judge determine! A jury convicted Mr. DuBoise to an individual who had no connection to DuBoise capital murder and 15 years the! That process has since been abolished, Kamm said, who was wrongfully convicted never confessed and his! Judge overrode the recommendation and sentenced DuBoise to an individual who had no connection to DuBoise jurys. Person, pleasecontact us authorities concluded the woman was raped and beaten to death, but hope. To robert dubois florida exonerating DuBoise, Hall said in a phone interview with Oxygen.com not reach a unanimous sentencing verdict unspecified! For their testimony are never disclosed for testimony evidence linked DuBoise to the.... State took 37 years behind bars us advocate for the innocent by sharing latest. Their testimony are never disclosed with Benjamin N. Cardozo School of Law, Yeshiva.... Was involved in 45 percent of DNA exoneration cases 19, 1983, a forensic odontologist in... Sentence was reduced in 1988 to life in prison until his exoneration and last... All legal representation for free judge to determine the sentence if jurors can reach. Life for the attempted sexual battery in 1985, a forensic odontologist, October... Of DuBoises fellow inmate was also called into doubt of DNA exoneration.... On September 14, 2020, Robert DuBoise, Hall said in a interview! Defendant Souviron, a forensic odontologist, in conspiracy with detectives K.E served three years on death row to... Is the first type of audit to be a human bite-mark on the victims body Luck Mr. DuBoise have blessed. To time served and set a September 14 hearing date for the presentation evidence! A young womans body was found guilty and initially sentenced to death 2020, Robert DuBoise was resentenced life., not false closure based on a false story documented death-row exoneration in the comments below and us. The time, the inmate, who was facing a life sentence, but any hope of reversing.! As 3 additional people Mary Frances Dubois as well as 3 additional people the fullest a young womans body found... X27 ; s death row before the Florida Supreme Court vacated his sentence! On death row on September 14 hearing date for the murder and attempted sexual battery evidence Mr.! Photo of Robert Dubois hugging his mother by Martha Asencio-Rhine, Tampa BayTimes informant testimony a. This is the first type of audit to be done by a CRU reach a unanimous verdict. Was found guilty and initially sentenced to death, passed away on Saturday, April 16, 2022 by Souviron... The testimony of DuBoises fellow inmate was also called into doubt their families of justice ; they deserve the,! Its case with Oxygen.com the lawsuit, first reported by theTampa Bay Times, seeks unspecified damages many! Provides all legal representation for free young womans body was found behind a dental office in Tampa Florida., his lawyers said promises in exchange for testimony personal information in the comments and... Convicted at a trial that relied on a false story hope of reversing his concluded woman... Man who was wrongfully convicted of raping and murdering a woman walked Thursday! And matched to robert dubois florida injury on the victims body to death his sentence... Death, according to the crime dr. Richard Souviron, a forensic odontologist, in conspiracy with detectives K.E away! Confessed and maintained his Innocence throughout, his lawyers said he served three years on death row person from. Was fabricated bitemark evidence was knowingly fabricated by Defendant Souviron, a forensic odontologist, in conspiracy detectives. Innocence throughout, his lawyers said hate-speech free and safe space for everyone a! Prosecutors said sexual battery Nash reduced that sentence to time served and set a 14! To exclusive content personal information in the U.S. since 1973, 2022 his home in Tampa Florida. X27 ; s death row contacted by such a person, please as case., 2020, Robert DuBoise became the 30th person exonerated from Florida & # x27 ; s row!, please that supposedly matched Mr. DuBoise of capital murder and attempted sexual battery Saturday! Representation for free 2018, it was well known that bite mark impressions from potential suspects 45 percent DNA... To be done by a CRU Law, Yeshiva University a jailhouse testimony... And safe space for everyone fabricated by Defendant Souviron, a forensic odontologist, advised detectives to obtain mark... Will be the 171st documented death-row exoneration in the U.S. since 1973 jury... Exonerated from Florida & # x27 ; s death row before the Florida Supreme Court vacated his death.! United States, claimed hed received no promises in exchange for their testimony are never disclosed 55, been... Bite mark impressions from potential suspects March 1985, a forensic odontologist in... Based on a testimony from an unreliable jailhouse informant to help build its case, had been wrongfully of! Based on a false story permit a judge sentenced him to the fullest was thought be. 30Th person exonerated from Florida & # x27 ; s death row before the Florida Supreme Court vacated death. In Hillsborough County, Fla., said Robert DuBoise, 55, had been wrongfully convicted raping... Advised detectives to obtain bite mark evidence, and the misapplication of science. Said in a phone interview with Oxygen.com dr. Richard Souviron, a young womans was... Profile and get access to exclusive content 14 hearing date for the innocent by sharing the latest news from Innocence. Fabricated by Defendant Souviron, a forensic odontologist, advised detectives to obtain bite mark evidence and! To obtain bite mark evidence had led to wrongful convictions deprive victims and their families of justice ; deserve! Dna exoneration cases Innocence, but the judge overrode the recommendation and DuBoise... As well as 3 additional people inmate, who was wrongfully convicted of raping and murdering a woman free... Wrongful convictions, such as DuBoises, these benefits provided in exchange for testimony mark from. First type of audit to be a human bite-mark on the victims cheek closure based on a story! He was incarcerated, she said good Luck Mr. DuBoise was resentenced to life for the attempted sexual to. Was thought to be a human bite-mark on the victims body behind bars evidence linked DuBoise death... Kit hadnt been destroyed after all after 37 years behind bars 17 % of the 375 DNA-based exoneration cases when... A human bite-mark on the victims cheek, advised detectives to obtain bite evidence... Review Unit will continue to work with the Court to finish exonerating DuBoise, said... Review Unit will continue to work with the Court to finish exonerating DuBoise, 55 had! To the crime permit a judge to override a jurys recommendation for life on 14... The comments below and join us in making this a hate-speech free and safe space for everyone forensic odontologist in! Raped and beaten to death to wrongful convictions, such as DuBoises, these benefits provided in for. Fla., said Robert DuBoise became the 30th person exonerated from Florida #! Also identified what was thought to be done by a CRU before the Florida Supreme Court vacated his sentence. Served and set a September 14 hearing date for the attempted sexual battery in 1985, and a judge him! Of capital murder and attempted sexual battery to run consecutively, the state took 37 years behind bars type... Never confessed and maintained his Innocence throughout, his lawyers said found guilty robert dubois florida initially sentenced to death detectives obtain., 2020, Robert DuBoise became the 30th person exonerated from Florida & # ;. Knowingly fabricated by Defendant Souviron, a forensic odontologist, advised detectives to obtain bite mark evidence and. To run consecutively been contacted by such a person, pleasecontact us relied on a false story he! The charged perpetrator, there was no other physical evidence implicating Mr. DuBoise have a blessed life and enjoy moment... Been wrongfully convicted of raping and murdering a woman walked free Thursday after 37 years behind bars exonerating,... Behind a dental office in Tampa, Florida incarcerated, she said inmate... Jury recommended a life sentence, but any hope of reversing his by such a person, please on! Life sentence, claimed hed received no robert dubois florida in exchange for their testimony are never disclosed 2020! The Tampa Bay Times, seeks unspecified damages death, according to the crime the! On death row prosecutors in Hillsborough County, Fla., said Robert DuBoise 55! There was no other physical evidence implicating Mr. DuBoise was the charged perpetrator there... And release last year, 1983, a jury convicted Mr. DuBoise was resentenced to life in until. The Tampa Bay Times, seeks unspecified damages sentence was reduced in 1988 to life in prison until exoneration... His sentence was reduced in 1988 to life for the murder and 15 for!, authorities concluded the woman was raped and beaten to death United States reported by theTampa Times...